Take your toaster oven cooking to the next level with these toaster oven pan sets, bakeware, mini pans and more. Plus find out the 3 toaster oven essentials everyone should have and get 4 tips for keeping your new pans in good shape.
(Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, we receive a commission for purchases made using the links on this page.)
When it comes to cooking with a toaster oven there are only 3 things you need: the manual, an oven thermometer, and a baking sheet. Everything else falls into that nice to have category.
So let’s chat real quick about those 3 essentials and then we’ll get to the fun stuff. Like toaster oven pan sets and ALL the mini bakeware!
3 TOASTER OVEN ESSENTIALS
We want you to enjoy your toaster oven safely so the first thing to do is to read your toaster oven’s manual and follow it’s directions and recommendations.
Missing the manual?
No worries, most major manufacturers offer appliance manuals as free PDF’s on their company websites. Just Google your toaster oven’s manufacturer name and the model number.
Example: Oster Toaster Oven Model TSSTTVCG02 Manual
2. OVEN THERMOMETER
All ovens (big and small) can have unreliable temperature settings. The best way to combat a fussy toaster oven is with an inexpensive thermometer.
We paid $7 on Amazon for ours. Look for thermometers that have a steady base and/or the ability to hang.
Check out our Toaster Oven Temperature Guide for step-by-step directions on using a thermometer to find out how accurate your little oven is.
3. A BAKING PAN OR SHEET PAN
Most toaster ovens come with at least one baking sheet or roasting pan. Sometimes that pan and a few reliable toaster oven recipes are all you need to cook something delicious.
FULL-TIME TOASTER OVEN COOKING
While not essential, it is nice to have a few extra pans and accessories for your toaster oven. Things like mini loaf pans, small cake pans, or a roasting rack will help you get more out of cooking with your compact oven.
Below are some of the pan sets and bakeware that we use regularly along with a few tasty recipe recommendations. *Since toaster ovens and pan sizes vary greatly, make sure to review each pan’s measurements before purchasing.
TOASTER OVEN PAN SETS
A pan set is a great way to start using your toaster oven for more than just toast. Most sets include at least one tiny baking sheet, a baking pan and then some accessory like a muffin tin, baking/roasting rack, or pizza pan.
The sets below are geared towards small and medium-sized ovens. If you have a larger toaster oven/countertop oven Williams Sanoma has some very nice sets you might want to check out.
CLASSIC METAL BAKEWARE
Before you go buying a bunch of new pans dig around your cabinets. Standard metal bakeware like an 8-inch or 9-inch square baker, pie pans, an 8-inch or 9-inch round cake pan, or a loaf pan will give you loads of options for cooking and baking in your toaster oven. Below I’ve highlighted a few of the pans we use regularly.
Mini pans are cute and fun but I’ve got to warn you, they are crazy addictive. There are tons of available options and you’re going to want all of them. Below are some of our most-used mini pans.
Tip: To keep our collection from overtaking the house, I try to think of at least 3 things I’ll make with a pan before bringing it home.
4 Tips For Longer Lasting Toaster Oven Pans
We’ve cooked with the pans listed above for years, they have a few scrapes and scratches but for the most part, are in great condition. If you’re like me and don’t like to waste your money (or create unnecessary landfill additions) below are a few best practices for taking care of your pans.
- Handwash them. It’s okay to soak the pans but don’t submerge them in water (this may lead to rust). Even if the manufacturer says it’s okay to put a pan in the dishwasher, the detergents can discolor or corrode pans and damage nonstick coatings.
- Be conservative with cooking spray, it can leave a sticky residue. I’ve found the main culprit is any spray on the pan that is not covered by food. It gets ‘baked on’ and is difficult to remove.
- Keep metal utensils and knives away from your pans. Use wooden or silicone cooking utensils instead.
- For easy cleanup try a silicone baking mat. If you want to use foil just make sure to consult your manual and follow the manufacturer’s instructions.
What about glass pyrex dishes?
Those are a little trickier, check out our post for 4 Surprising Things You Should Never Use In A Toaster Oven for more information.