Learn how to make a toaster oven baked grilled cheese sandwich. Perfect golden crispy bread and gooey melted cheese – no stovetop required!
Looking for a basic toaster oven ‘grilled cheese’ recipe? One that doesn’t require flipping the sandwich while it cooks AND has that perfectly crispy (not crunchy) texture you remember from your childhood?
Then this is the recipe for you!
It’s a mashup of the methods used in our original Toaster Oven Grilled Cheese Sandwich (preheating the pan) and this Toasted Caprese Sandwich (cooking open-faced and adding extra fresh fillings later).
The result is a classic-style grilled cheese with crispy golden bread and oozing plenty of melted cheese.
What Ingredients Do You Need For A Grilled Cheese Sandwich?
To make a basic grilled cheese you only need bread + cheddar cheese + butter or mayonnaise.
But if you’re feeling a little adventurous try one (or all) of these upgrades:
- Add a smear of fruit preserves or mustard.
- Swap the cheddar for a spicy pepper jack cheese.
- Toss on a small handful of fresh spinach just before serving.
Whether you keep things simple or get creative, you can’t go wrong with this easy toaster oven recipe.
* You may need more or less mayonnaise or butter depending on the size/type of bread used. You’re aiming for a thin layer, too much and your bread will be soggy and greasy instead of crispy. For a vegetarian sandwich use cheese that lists microbial/non-animal rennet or enzymes on the ingredients list. As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
Nutrition Information:Yield: 1 Serving Size: 1 Sandwich
Amount Per Serving:Calories: 353 Total Fat: 16.3g Saturated Fat: 7.8g Cholesterol: 39mg Sodium: 794mg Carbohydrates: 42.1g Fiber: 14.2g Sugar: 11g Protein: 18.9g
* You may need more or less mayonnaise or butter depending on the size/type of bread used. You’re aiming for a thin layer, too much and your bread will be soggy and greasy instead of crispy.
For a vegetarian sandwich use cheese that lists microbial/non-animal rennet or enzymes on the ingredients list.
As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.
How to Make a Toaster Oven Baked Grilled Cheese
Step 1: Heat Up Your Pan
Start by adjusting your cooking rack to the bottom position and sticking your pan in the toaster oven (or countertop oven) before preheating. Pro Tip: Make sure your bread slices fit in the pan side-by-side first.
Next, preheat your toaster oven to 400°F on the BAKE setting.
Step 2: Prep Your Slices
Lay the bread slices on a cutting board and spread each one with a thin layer of mayonnaise. Butter works great too but I like that you don’t have to wait for the mayo to soften and it adds a subtle tang.
Flip the slices over and spread with a little apricot preserves. This is totally optional, but if you’re using pepper jack cheese, the contrasting sweet and spicy flavors are delicious.
Lastly, divide the shredded cheese over each slice of bread.
Step 3: Bake Your Sandwich
Put on some oven gloves or mitts and carefully remove the hot pan. As you add the bread slices (cheese-side-up) you should hear a little sizzle when each one hits the pan.
Return the pan to the toaster oven and cook until the bread is golden on the bottom and the cheese is melted and bubbly (but not browned), about 6 to 7 minutes.
Step 4: Assembly
Remove the pan from the oven and use a spatula to transfer the slices to your cutting board. Cover one cheesy piece with the fresh spinach, top with the remaining slice, and devour!