Toaster Oven Roasted Red Peppers

Toaster oven roasted red peppers make a flavorful addition to any meal, from pizza to frittatas and everything in between! They’re great to have on hand and can even be frozen.

Cooked red peppers on a dark roasting pan with tongs.

From the grill to the stovetop, there are a lot of ways to roast bell peppers.

If you’re roasting just one or two peppers then your toaster oven is the right appliance for the job.

Why should you roast bell peppers?

Roasting bell peppers (any color-not just the red ones) gives them a meaty texture, smoky flavor and intensifies their natural sweetness.

Also, the thicker skin (which upsets some people’s digestion) is easy to remove after roasting.

The sweet and tender peppers taste fantastic in vegetarian sandwiches like this Roasted Red Pepper, Carrot and Hummus Sandwich and are the perfect addition to a toaster oven frittata.

Roasted Red Pepper Hummus Sandwich on a wooden cutting board.

Today we’re sharing two easy methods for roasting red peppers in a toaster oven:

  1. The first takes a little longer and uses the “Bake” function. It’s a great option if your oven’s broiler cooks unevenly.
  2. The second option is super quick and uses the “Broil” function.

Regardless of the method you choose, you’ll always end up with a tasty batch of sweet and juicy roasted red peppers!

~ Keep scrolling for step by step photos & toaster oven tips after the recipe ~

Cooked red peppers with blackened spots on a roasting pan.

Toaster Oven Roasted Red Peppers

Prep Time: 5 minutes
Cook Time: 15 minutes
Total Time: 20 minutes

Toaster oven roasted red peppers make a flavorful addition to any meal, from pizzas to sandwiches and everything in between!

Ingredients

  • whole red bell peppers, washed and dried
  • oil for the pan

Instructions

  1. Adjust the toaster oven cooking rack to the middle position and heat to 425°F. Lightly oil a roasting pan.
  2. Slice the peppers in half lengthwise. Remove the stem, seeds and any large pieces of the white pith.
  3. Place the peppers cut side down on a cutting board and use the palm of your hand to gently press down and flatten them. Arrange flattened peppers skin side up on the prepared pan.
  4. Roast peppers until they have begun to collapse and the skins are wrinkled and bubbled with black spots (12 to 20 minutes depending on the size of the peppers and your toaster oven).
  5. Quickly remove the peppers from the pan and transfer to a shallow covered container. Place lid on container and leave for at least 10 minutes to steam.
  6. Once the peppers are cooled enough to handle rub the skins off with your hands or with a paper towel.
  7. Leave the peppers whole or slice into strips or chunks before returning them to the covered container.
  8. Store refrigerated for 2-3 days or slice and freeze for up to 3 months.

Notes

To Broil Your Peppers: Use the top rack position and broil the peppers for 8 to 10 minutes.

Broiler Tips: The broiler element on our larger toaster oven was too intense and blackened the peppers before they had softened slightly. If you've got a strong broiler, for the best results adjust the rack to the middle position or Broil using a Medium temperature setting.

Cooking method adapted from Vegetarian Cooking For Everyone.

Nutrition Information:
Yield: 1 Serving Size: 1 Medium Roasted Red Pepper
Amount Per Serving: Calories: 37Total Fat: 0gSaturated Fat: 0gTrans Fat: 0gCholesterol: 0mgCarbohydrates: 7gFiber: 2gSugar: 5gProtein: 1g

How to Roast Bell Peppers In Your Toaster Oven

A red pepper sliced open and seeded on a cutting board.

Start by slicing your peppers in half.

By halving the peppers (instead of keeping them whole) you won’t have to turn or flip them while they roast. 

Next, seed them and remove the flavorless white ribs.

Then, gently press the pepper halves as flat and even as you can. 

Don’t press too hard or you’ll burst the pepper’s cell walls. This will cause your peppers to lose a lot of their juicy flavor and make them dry.

Red pepper halves on a toaster oven baking pan.

You want to cook the peppers until their skins are wrinkled and bubbled with black spots.

For each cooking method below, the time is just a guideline.

  • Roasting: Adjust the cooking rack to the middle position, set the “Bake” function on your toaster oven and heat to 425°F. Place peppers inside and roast for about 12 to 20 minutes depending on the size of the peppers.
  • Broiling: Adjust the cooking rack to the top or middle position, place peppers in your toaster oven and select the Broil function. Broil peppers for about 8 to 10 minutes.

Roasted red peppers with blackened spots on a roasting pan.

Once your peppers are ready, you need to steam them to loosen their skins for removal.

Some people use a paper bag or bowl covered with plastic wrap.

Cooked red peppers steaming in a covered container.

We like to skip the plastic wrap and use the container and lid we intend to store the finished peppers in instead.

You could also transfer them to a plastic bag to steam or a bowl covered with a plate.

Whatever method you choose, the key is stacking them on top of one another so the steam can loosen their skin.

Once the peppers have cooled enough to be handled (about 10 minutes) you can peel off and discard the skins.

Red peppers in a bowl with their skin peeled back.

Don’t try to get every last piece of skin off, a few roasted bits are okay.

Also, avoid rinsing the peppers with water, it will wash away all of their flavors too.

You can even mix the juices in the bottom of the bowl with a little oil and vinegar to make a tasty salad dressing!

Tasty Ways to Enjoy Your Roasted Red Peppers:

Baked toaster oven fritatta in a mini cast iron skillet.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *