Lemon olive oil cupcakes are light, tender, simple to throw together (no mixer required!) and bake up in just 15 minutes. Are six cupcakes too much for your small household? Don’t worry, the leftovers freeze great!
(Quick Note: This post contains affiliate links, as an Amazon Associate we earn commissions from qualifying purchases.)
If you’ve got a small household you’re going to love this easy lemon olive oil cupcakes recipe. It’s the perfect size for just one or two people.
The recipe’s adapted from my favorite Christmas gift, Mark Bittman’s How To Bake Everything Cookbook (affiliate). His original Olive Oil Cake recipe tastes fantastic.
But it makes 12 to 16 servings!
The responsibility to dispatch ALL of that cake before it goes stale is too much for the two of us.
Plus, I don’t know about you but I can’t trust myself with that many sweets in the house.
But just six light and tender, not-too-sweet cupcakes featuring the lovely combination of olive oil and lemon?
That’s the right amount.
You can enjoy one or two today and then freeze the rest.
Simply wrap any leftover plain cupcakes individually in plastic wrap and toss in a freezer safe bag. The bag will take up less space than your ice tray and you’ll have a sweet treat ready when a craving strikes!
~ Keep scrolling for step by step photos & toaster oven baking tips after the recipe ~
How to Make Lemon Olive Oil Cupcakes
This recipe uses simple ingredients with lots of room to customize and make these cupcakes your own. So have fun experimenting with different types of citrus like oranges, limes, grapefruit, or clementines.
The batter couldn’t be easier to throw together:
- Whisk the dry ingredients.
- Whisk the wet ingredients.
- Fold them together and bake. Easy, peasy.
Two important things to note about the batter; it will be thinner and have tiny lumps.
Are you an over-mixer?
I’m notorious for over-mixing cake batter. The Virgo in me wants a perfectly smooth batter. All that mixing though leads to a tough cake with LOTS of large holes.
So just make sure there are no big lumps and then get that batter in your pan and quickly into the toaster oven.
{Related: What Are The Best Toaster Oven Pans?}
Once your baked cupcakes have cooled you can finish them off with a light glaze of lemon juice and honey, strawberries, and whipped cream or Tim’s favorite a scoop of vanilla ice cream.
Give yourself permission to go a little overboard, after all, it’s only one special cupcake.
Baking Cupcakes With Convection
Like all of our recipes, this one was originally written and tested using a conventional toaster oven but we’ve included directions for using a convection toaster oven too.
If you’ve never tried baking with your toaster oven’s convection function check out this post for Everything You Need to Know About Convection Toaster Ovens and you’ll be set.
Tips For Baking This Recipe With Convection:
- Use the lower rack placement. (We tried a batch on the middle rack and it was too close to the fan, the cupcakes did rise more but they were dried out and cracked on top)
- Reduce the temperature by 25 degrees to 325℉
- Start testing for doneness 2/3 through the cooking time (about 10 minutes).
Mary E Spierl says
I am a seasoned baker & wanted something for 6 cupcakes however this only made 5 full cupcakes. So won’t do it again. Better to make too many rather than not enough.
Brie says
Sorry to hear this recipe wasn’t for you, Mary.
Happy Holidays!
D,davies says
My tower toaster oven dose not give or show how to set the heating for cakes or the air fry instructions
Brie says
I’d never heard of a tower toaster oven before, had to do a quick Google.
This is the one I found, not sure if it’s the same one you have? If it is, there is not a convection feature on that toaster oven (not all of them have it) there is just a conventional “Bake” setting on the left knob.
There is a link to the “User’s Guide” on the page that gives specific instructions for using the bake setting. It looks like you are not able to adjust the temperature.
Unfortunately, the guide does not say what temperature the “Bake” setting is regulated too. You might want to give the manufacturer a call and see what assistance/info they can offer beyond the manual?
Update: Sorry I didn’t think of this sooner, the easiest way to find out the actual temperature is to toss an oven thermometer in there before preheating. Here’s our step-by-step guide explaining how to test your toaster oven’s temperature.
grace says
i love filled cupcakes! especially when the combination of flavors is so awesome. fantastic small batch!
Mary Ann says
This is a tech difficulty. I am unable to download into Paprika recipe app, either through the app download or by cutting and pasting from the website in Safari. Only one line at a time will highlight, which is way too cumbersome even for the best recipe.
Brie says
Sorry you’re having trouble saving the recipe, Mary Ann. I’m not familiar with the Paprika app but I think I know the problem. This recipe was originally posted on Food Fanatic so the recipe card is hosted by them.
Try visiting this page https://www.foodfanatic.com/recipes/lemon-olive-oil-cupcakes-recipe/ and saving from there.
If you’re still having trouble shoot me an email and we’ll get you taken care of 🙂